OBJECTS · SESSION 6

What's the oldest piece of technology you own?

Three of you, cold, before anything is taught. I am counting the seconds and writing three words for each answer on the board.

16 students · nothing written · no recording, no test

the whole set, from the bank

Eight questions about objects

5 min
1How much time do you spend on your phone?
2What do you use it for most?
3Is there an app you could not live without?
4Do you prefer to read on paper or on a screen?
5Has technology changed your evenings?
6Do you buy things online?
7What is the oldest piece of technology you own?
8Do you think you use technology too much?
This is one set of four. Clothes, gifts and books ask the same things.

however it is worded, you are saying one of these

Seven things, thirty-two questions

6 min
What it is, when you got it8the oldest technology you own
What you think of it6an app you could not live without
How much you use it5time on your phone, what for
Which one you'd pick4paper or a screen
How it has changed, in you3technology and your evenings
What people here do3do people dress differently now
What you'd like3something expensive you'd like
The number is how many of the thirty-two ask for it. That order is the order we work in.

eight of the thirty-two, and the anchor for the topic

What it is, and when you got it

8 min
ModelThe oldest thing I own is a laptop I bought in 2016, in my second year. It cost about four hundred, which was two months of tutoring, and the battery died in 2020 so it lives on a desk now.
Three facts under every object answer: since when, what it cost, where it came from.
A date and a price. If the answer has neither, you have not said what it is.

questions about what you own

Six ways to pin an object

7 min
When
  • I've had it since 2021
  • I've had it for about five years
  • it's coming up to six years
Where from
  • my sister gave it to me when she upgraded
  • I bought it second-hand from a classmate
  • it came with the flat, honestly
What it cost, and its state
  • about four hundred, which was a lot then
  • it was a present, so nothing
  • there's a chip on the corner, and the battery's dead
"I have it for five years" is wrong. "I've had it for five years."

six of the thirty-two, and the limit is the whole thing

What you think of it

5 min
ModelI wouldn't call it essential exactly, but I'd notice if it went. Everything I've written since 2016 is on it, so losing it would cost me a weekend, not a morning.
View, then the evidence that costs you something, then the sentence that limits the view.
"It's very useful" is not an opinion. It is an adjective with no evidence and no limit.

the sentence that separates a view from an opinion

I wouldn't call it essential exactly

6 min
Limit first
  • I wouldn't call it essential exactly, but
  • it's not something I'd miss, though
  • honestly, I think I use it too much
Evidence that costs
  • everything I've written since then is on it
  • I'd replace it the same day
  • I've had the same one for six years
Verdict with a condition
  • I'd recommend it, but only if you write for a living
  • it's worth it at that price, not at full price
  • it's fine, it's just not something I'd miss
One limit per answer. Two and it sounds like you are arguing with yourself.

five of the thirty-two, and the easiest to answer badly

How much you use it

5 min
1How much time do you spend on your phone?
2What do you use it for most?
6Do you buy things online?
B1Do you read much?
B4When do you usually read?
Three parts, every time: how often, at what time of day, and what for.
"A lot" answers none of the three.

quantity in a spoken sentence

How often, when, and what for

6 min
How often
  • two or three hours a day, more at the weekend
  • maybe twice a week
  • I've cut down since I started working
When
  • first thing, before I get up properly
  • on the metro, both ways
  • in the evening, once the flat is quiet
What for
  • notes in class, and nothing else
  • mostly messages, and maps when I'm lost
  • I buy everything online except food
"Very much" is not a quantity. "Everyday" is not an adverb. A number is a quantity.

four of the thirty-two, all phrased as a choice

Which one you'd pick

5 min
ModelPaper, easily, though I read screens all day at work. A screen is faster for finding something and paper is better for remembering it, so the paper stays for anything I need to keep.
Two things, one dimension, a verdict. The dimension is the sentence everyone forgets.
"Paper is better" is not a comparison. Better at what?

the four preference questions in the bank

Better at what

5 min
The two things
  • paper, easily, though I read screens all day
  • comfortable, because I'm standing for nine hours
  • useful, but I'd rather be given something useless and funny
The dimension
  • faster for finding it, worse for remembering it
  • it survives a winter, and the cheap ones do not
  • it's the only one anyone actually notices
The verdict, with a condition
  • so the paper stays for anything I need to keep
  • smart clothes, but only when someone is watching
  • neither, really. I'd pick whichever is clean
One dimension, said once. Two dimensions and the answer turns into a list.

three of the thirty-two, and the one nobody can answer from their own life

What people here do

6 min
ModelOn the whole, yes. Most people I know read on their phones on the metro, and the ones who still buy paper are over forty, so I'd say it has changed in the last five years.
A generalisation, a hedge, and one thing you have actually seen. Present tense throughout.
The question says "people in your country". An answer about yourself does not answer it.

the whole set of them

Three questions that are not about you

5 min
1Do people in your country dress differently from ten years ago?
2Do people in your country give gifts often?
3Do people in your country read enough?
Four of you, twelve seconds each. One generalisation, one hedge, one thing you have seen.
Not everyone. Not all of us. Most people I know.

three of the thirty-two, and tense does the work

How it has changed, in you

5 min
ModelIt used to be an hour of reading before bed. Now it's two hours of a screen and I don't remember any of it, and what changed was the phone, honestly.
Before, now, one cause. The cause is a thing, not a feeling.
"Because I grew up" is not a cause. A phone is a cause.

three of the thirty-two, and the easiest to pad

What you'd like

5 min
ModelI'd like a proper camera, but I'd never use it. I take everything on my phone, so it would sit in a drawer, and I'd rather spend that money on going somewhere worth photographing.
What you want, why you do not have it, and what you would actually do.
One wish. Three wishes is a list, and a list has no reason in it.

every category, once each

Fifteen seconds each

10 min
1I name you, then I ask. No thinking time.
2One question each, and the seven categories in turn.
3If something is missing I say one word: anchor, limit, dimension, cause.
4Twelve of you. Nobody repeats a question until the seventh name.
Fifteen seconds is not enough time to prepare, which is the point

the class pattern, not a person

Where this room failed

live
1 what it is, when you got it 
2 what you think of it 
3 how much you use it 
4 which one you'd pick 
5 how it has changed, in you 
6 what people here do 
7 what you'd like 

One mark per failure, from what you just heard. Sixteen students, seven rows.

Whatever row is longest is what the last twenty minutes teaches

the real thing, no score

Four minutes at exam pace

14 min
1You, then three object topics, four questions each.
2No thinking time between questions. One follow-up each.
3The room listens for one thing: did the answer stop before the shape was finished.
4One comment each, about a shape, never a score.
No band, no ranking, nobody's name attached to a number

closing the loop

What's the oldest piece of technology you own?

6 min

Two students who did not answer at minute nought. No warning, no preparation, seconds counted.

Then: which of the seven things could you say now that you could not at the start?

nothing written

Bring two objects

4 min
1One you use every day, with a date, a price and a condition.
2One you have kept, or one someone gave you.
3Nothing written. Say each one through once before you sleep.
All seven things, not eight questions. I open the next session with three names, cold
1 / 15